SUSAN CAN CAKE IT
Cookies + Cake
Welcome to Fall.
Cookies + Cake
​
Simple. Delicious.
​
Fall Offerings
Cookies
Classic Shortbread
Flakey, buttery and a touch of salt...mmm!
Doz.
$12.00
Fall Spice Shortbread
Classic shortbread with a touch of fall spices--perfect for a crisp fall day.
Doz.
$12.00
Pumpkin Spice Cookie (3 oz)
Brown butter + maple syrup + pumpkin + spices = chewy deliciousness.
1/2 Doz.
$23
Doz.
$45
Chocolate Chip Cookie (3 oz)
Chocolate Chips + Chunks + a touch of salt.
1/2 Doz.
$23
Doz.
$45
Chocolate Chip Cookie (1.5 oz)
Perfect for a cookie tray or lunch box.
Doz.
$24
Pumpkin Spice Cookie (1.5 oz)
Perfect for a cookie tray.
Doz.
$24
Gift: Shortbread Treat
Vanilla or fall spice shortbread in a pretty package.
$3.50
Gift: Big Cookie (~3 oz)
Pumpkin Spice or Chocolate Chip in a pretty wrapper, with a little gift tag to express your thanks.
Pumpkin Spice
$4.00
Chocolate Chip
$4.00
GF Shortbread
Flakey, buttery, gluten-free
$15.00
Cakes
Lemon Cornmeal Cake
Freshly squeezed lemon + fresh zest = a lemony delight. A beautiful addition to any table and a welcomed hostess gift.
6" Round Gift Box
$24.50
Lemon Rosemary Cornmeal Cake
Lemony, with a rosemary whisper. A beautiful addition to any table and a welcomed hostess gift.
6" Round Gift Box
$24.50
Cake
Chocolate or vanilla cake with chocolate or vanilla buttercream frosting. Let's talk.
$65
About Us
Susan Can Cake It LLC It is a homegrown Cottage Food Operation based in Eagle, Idaho.
​All food is prepared in a home kitchen that is not subject to regulation and inspection by the regulatory authority.
The food may contain allergens.
Susan approaches challenges with a 'fake it til you make it' attitude. With the help of her crew (a.k.a. family and taste testing neighbors), Susan Can Cake It has grown into an award winning operation, with a 1st place blue ribbon for her gluten-free shortbread (2024) and a 3rd place white ribbon for her Lemon Rosemary Cornmeal Cake (2025), both from the Western Idaho Fair.
​
While Susan still makes cakes, she has expanded into cookies and other baked treats.
And while she does (clearly) enjoy playing in the kitchen, most of all
she loves meeting people and sharing in their delight over simple, delicious treats.
And at the end of the day, that is what drives Susan Can Cake It.
​
As each has received a gift,
use it to serve one another, as good stewards of God's varied grace:
1 Peter 4:10
